Care payment claims and unjust enrichment

older woman smiling at another woman

Care payment claims and unjust enrichment

For peace of mind

Providing care for an elderly or vulnerable family member can be a significant commitment, often involving considerable time, financial sacrifice and changes to your own life. While many people take on caring responsibilities out of love and family duty, there may be circumstances where an expectation of payment has been established.

If you have provided substantial care for a family member who has since died, you may be entitled to make a claim against their estate for payment. Equally, if you are an executor or beneficiary facing a claim for unpaid care, it is important to understand your legal position.

At Switalskis, our contentious probate and trusts solicitors can advise on claims for payment for family care, including contractual claims and claims based on unjust enrichment. We can help you understand your options, assess the evidence and take steps to protect your interests.

yorkshire dales countryside

What is a care payment claim?

A care payment claim may arise where someone has provided significant care and support to a family member on the understanding that they would receive payment in return.

This could involve:

  • Providing full-time or live-in care for an elderly parent.
  • Giving up employment or reducing working hours to look after a relative.
  • Providing personal care and assistance with everyday activities.
  • Taking responsibility for a family member's long-term health and wellbeing.
  • Making significant changes to your home or lifestyle to accommodate their care needs.

In some circumstances, an agreement to pay for care may be legally enforceable, even if it was made informally between family members.

Where the person receiving care has died without making payment, the person who provided the care may be able to pursue a claim against their estate.

Read what our clients had to say about the help they received from Switalskis

Can I claim payment for looking after a family member?

Whether you can claim payment will depend on the circumstances and the evidence available.

A claim may be possible where there was an agreement, either express or implied, that you would be paid for providing care. This does not necessarily mean that a specific hourly rate or total amount must have been agreed in advance.

The court may consider whether there was an intention to create a legally binding agreement and whether the circumstances support an obligation to pay a reasonable amount for the services provided.

Relevant evidence could include:

  • Conversations or written agreements about payment.
  • Text messages, emails or letters discussing the caring arrangement.
  • Statements made by the person receiving care to other family members.
  • Evidence of the extent and duration of the care provided.
  • Financial records showing expenses incurred.
  • Medical records and assessments demonstrating the level of care required.
  • Evidence of employment or income sacrificed to provide care.

It is important to remember that not every family caring arrangement will create a legal right to payment. The court will look carefully at the circumstances, including whether the care was intended to be provided voluntarily or in return for remuneration.

The legal grounds for contesting a will are as follows:

Lack of testamentary capacity

The person making the will (the testator) must have had the mental capacity to understand the implications of creating the will at the time it was made. This means that they are capable of making their own decisions, and that they are able to consider all of the following:

  • Why they are making a will and what effect it will have
  •  That the will is legally binding and overrules any previous will
  • The full extent of their estate
  • Any potential claims from beneficiaries and financial dependants

You may need medical evidence or statements from witnesses to support claims of a and challenge the will on these grounds. It is important to keep in mind, that conditions such as dementia or other could support your claim. However, all evidence available should be considered by a legal professional before you know if your claim has prospect of success.

Lack of valid execution

For a will to be valid in England and Wales, it must comply with the requirements of the Wills Act 1837, which include:

  • The will must be in writing.
  • It must be signed by the testator (or someone else in their presence and by their direction).
  • The signature must be made or acknowledged in the presence of two witnesses present at the same time.
  • Each witness must sign the will or acknowledge their signature in the testator's presence.

While witnesses previously had to be in the same room as the person making the will, the will can now be signed over a video call. However, this has introduced some ambiguity about certain wills and whether or not they meet the requirements to be legally valid. Failing to meet any of the above requirements will render the will invalid and may be grounds for contesting it.

Undue influence

A will can be contested if you believe that the testator was coerced or unduly influenced into making or altering the will. This could involve manipulation, pressure, or threats from someone seeking to benefit unfairly. This can be challenging, as the presumption of coercion does not arise automatically, and you must prove that actual undue influence took place to contest a will on these grounds.

In order to bring a case based on undue influence, we will take into account all relevant information in regards to your family circumstances. This could include personal correspondance, previous wills, medical or social care notes and your family history more generally.

Fraud or forgery

If you can prove that the will was forged or fraudulently created, you can challenge it. This might require evidence that the testator’s signature was forged or that they were deceived about the contents of the will. Evidence such as handwriting analysis or witness testimony may be required to substantiate these claims.

Lack of knowledge and approval

The testator must have known and approved the content of the will. Contesting a will may be possible if there are suspicions that the testator did not understand or agree to the provisions. This could be due to any number of reasons - for example, if they were illiterate or had a visual impairment, and relied on someone else to write the document for them because they could not do so for themselves. If instructions were taken from a different person than the testator, such as a relative, this can also indicate that the testator may not have understood the will’s contents. Wills prepared under unusual circumstances or where the provisions do not match the person making the will's stated intentions could face scrutiny under this ground. This ground can often be interlinked with the lack of capacity.

Even if a will is valid, certain people can contest it if they believe it fails to make reasonable financial provision for them. They can do this through Claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Spouses, civil partners, children and other people who were financially dependent on the deceased may be eligible to make an Inheritance Act claim.

The following individuals can bring a claim:

  • The testator's spouse or civil partner;
  • A former spouse or civil partner (if the person did not remarry);
  • A cohabitee who lived with the deceased;
  • The testator's children (or people treated as children by the testator); and
  • Other financial dependants who were maintained by the deceased

Inheritance Act claims must usually be made within six months of a grant of probate being issued, so it's important to seek legal advice at your earliest opportunity.

What is unjust enrichment?

Unjust enrichment is a legal principle that may allow someone to recover the value of a benefit provided to another person where it would be unjust for that benefit to be retained without payment.

In the context of family care, a claim may arise where someone has provided substantial services to a relative, knowing or expecting that they would be paid, but no payment has been made.

To establish an unjust enrichment claim, it is generally necessary to demonstrate:

  • Enrichment: The person receiving the care benefited from the services provided.
  • At the claimant's expense: The person providing the care incurred the cost, time or sacrifice involved in delivering those services.
  • Unjust factor: There is a recognised legal reason why it would be unjust for the benefit to be retained without payment.

One example is the principle of free acceptance. This may apply where someone knowingly accepts services that they should reasonably understand are being provided with an expectation of payment but does not reject them despite having a reasonable opportunity to do so.

A claim based on unjust enrichment may be particularly relevant where there was no clear or enforceable contract setting out the terms of payment.

However, the legal requirements are complex, and the fact that someone has provided unpaid care does not automatically mean they are entitled to compensation.

Defending a care payment claim against an estate

Not every claim for payment for family care will be successful. Executors and beneficiaries may find themselves facing claims from relatives who believe they are entitled to compensation for care provided before someone died.

If you are an executor or beneficiary dealing with a care payment claim, it is important to establish whether there was a genuine agreement to pay for the services and whether the amount being claimed is reasonable.

Factors that may need to be considered include:

  • Whether the person receiving care agreed to make payment.
  • Whether they had the mental capacity to enter into an agreement at the relevant time.
  • Whether the care was intended to be provided voluntarily as part of a family arrangement.
  • The extent and nature of the care actually provided.
  • Whether the amount claimed reflects the services delivered.
  • Whether there is sufficient evidence to support the claim.

Our contentious probate solicitors can advise executors, beneficiaries and other interested parties on challenging or responding to claims against an estate.

How can Switalskis help with a care payment claim?

Claims involving unpaid family care can be particularly sensitive, especially where disagreements arise between relatives following someone's death.

Our specialist contentious probate and trusts team understands the legal and personal complexities involved in these disputes. We provide clear, practical advice to help you understand your rights and decide on the best way forward.

We can help with:

  • Assessing your claim: Reviewing the circumstances of the caring arrangement and advising whether you may have grounds for a contractual or unjust enrichment claim.
  • Gathering evidence: Identifying the documents, communications and other evidence needed to support your case.
  • Calculating reasonable payment: Considering the extent of the care provided and the potential value of your claim.
  • Making a claim against an estate: Advising on the appropriate legal route to seek payment for care provided.
  • Defending claims: Representing executors and beneficiaries who are facing claims for unpaid family care.
  • Negotiation and mediation: Exploring opportunities to resolve disputes without the need for court proceedings.
  • Court proceedings: Providing representation where a settlement cannot be reached.

We understand that these disputes often arise at an already difficult time. Our approach combines specialist legal knowledge with a sensitive and straightforward service, helping you navigate the complexities with confidence.

Speak to our contentious probate solicitors

If you have provided care for a family member and believe you may be entitled to payment, or you are dealing with a claim against an estate for unpaid care, our team can help.

Contact Switalskis to discuss your circumstances and find out how we can support you.

Call us today or complete our online enquiry form to speak to a member of our team.

Got questions or ready to get going? Just give us a ring on 0800 1380 458 or drop us a line through the website. Whenever you need us, we're here to help.

Our contentious probate team

Sandra Kowalska
Sandra KowalskaContentious Probate Senior Associate Solicitor
Kelsey Jones Headshot
Kelsey JonesParalegal
Aleksandar Cvetkov Trainee Solicitor
View more

Our contentious probate updates

View more

Why Switalskis?

Deciding to issue court proceedings or a legal challenge to a will can be daunting, and add emotional strain at a time when you're already dealing with the grief of losing a loved one. With Switalskis, you won't have to face this difficult time alone. We'll stand by you throughout your case, from when you first suspect that a deceased person's will is invalid, to any legal proceedings that arise and beyond, our experienced contentious probate team will offer advice and guidance to help you reach the best possible outcome. Our approach is founded on the following commitments:

Clarity in complexity

Switalskis is here to break down all complexity and make the legal matters easier to understand. We're committed to communicating clearly and to making sure you understand your position and what you need to do at all stages of the legal process.

Empathy at every step

Our contentious probate specialists understand that dealing with legal proceedings after the death of a loved one is very difficult and can stir up a lot of emotions. We offer an empathetic ear so that, no matter what you're going through, you can talk to us about it. We'll take on as much of the legal legwork as possible to help you focus on the personal side of things, and relieve your stress.

Expertise you can trust

Switalskis' experts have a lot of experience in dealing with care payments which means that we understand the situation from both sides. That gives us an overall perspective that can help you to make the best decisions based on the specifics of your case. We'll give you a realistic assessment of the situation and the likely outcomes so you feel empowered to move forward, and always offer practical advice to help you achieve your desired outcome.

Championing your rights

We’re committed to protecting your rights and helping you understand your options when disputes arise over family care payments. Our specialist solicitors provide clear, practical advice and sensitive support, guiding you through the legal process and working towards a fair resolution.

Find out how Switalskis can help you

If you're considering contesting probate and want to know the best way to go about it, our contentious probate team is here to offer advice that's tailored to you.

Give our specialist contentious probate team a call on 0800 138 0458 or send us a message through our website to get things moving.

When completing this form, the details you provide will only be used to deal with your enquiry. Please read our Privacy Policy for more information on how your data is used and stored.

Contact us