News & Blog

For the latest industry and case news

Court or Mediation? How Most Probate Disputes Are Actually Resolved

By Kelsey Jones

Published In: Contentious Probate

When people think about contentious probate, they often picture a dramatic court battle.

In reality, most probate disputes never reach trial.

Many are resolved through negotiation or mediation long before a judge becomes involved.

Woman testifying on court stand for child abuse

Does every probate dispute go to court?

No.

Before court proceedings are issued, parties are encouraged to exchange information, disclose key documents and explore possible settlement options.

In many cases, this process uncovers misunderstandings or identifies areas where compromise is possible.

What is mediation?

Mediation is one of the most common ways of resolving probate disputes.

Rather than asking a judge to decide the outcome, the parties meet with an independent mediator who helps them negotiate a settlement.

Mediation is often attractive because it is:

  • Private
  • Flexible
  • Usually quicker than litigation
  • Less expensive than a trial
  • Better at preserving family relationships

When is court necessary?

Some disputes simply cannot be resolved through negotiation.

Where settlement is not possible, court proceedings may be required. Depending on the case, this may involve:

  • Witness evidence
  • Disclosure of documents
  • Expert evidence
  • A trial before a judge

Court proceedings can be lengthy, expensive and emotionally draining, particularly where family members are already in conflict.

What about legal costs?

Costs are a significant consideration in probate disputes.

The court has wide powers when deciding who should pay costs and may take into account how parties have behaved throughout the dispute. This can include whether someone has unreasonably refused to engage in mediation or other forms of alternative dispute resolution.

Takeaway

Most contentious probate disputes are resolved without a trial. Whilst court proceedings remain an important option when agreement cannot be reached, mediation and early negotiation often provide a faster, less expensive and less damaging route to resolution.

Find out how Switalskis can help you

If you're considering contesting probate and want to know the best way to go about it, our contentious probate team is here to offer advice that's tailored to you.

Give our specialist contentious probate team a call on 0800 138 0458 or send us a message through our website to get things moving.

When completing this form, the details you provide will only be used to deal with your enquiry. Please read our Privacy Policy for more information on how your data is used and stored.

Back to News & Blog
Share this post
Kelsey Jones Headshot

5 years’ experience working in the legal profession focusing on complex litigation and dealing with vulnerable clients.

Paralegal

News, views and information from us and the industry

Related posts

Contact us