An amputation is a life-changing event. It affects every aspect of a person’s life - mentally, physically and emotionally. For those affected, the trauma is lifelong and concerns about whether a procedure was necessary can cause further distress. Recent news surrounding Neil Hopper, a former consultant vascular surgeon, has understandably raised serious questions among patients and the wider public.

Serious allegations

Neil Hopper, who carried out hundreds of amputations during his time at Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust (RCHT) is facing criminal charges including fraud and encouraging the removal of body parts. He was employed by RCHT from 2013 until his arrest in March 2023 and has been suspended from the medical register since December 2023. He is scheduled to appear at Truro Crown Court in September 2025.

Although RCHT has stated that these charges do not relate to Mr Hopper’s professional conduct, the gravity of the case highlights the importance of transparency and thorough investigation. Many patients who underwent amputations are now understandably asking: Was my surgery necessary? Could it have been avoided?

As solicitors specialising in medical negligence, we find cases like this profoundly disturbing. The decision to remove part of a person’s body must be approached with the highest level of care, as amputation is irreversible and can drastically diminish independence. Except in emergencies, it should always follow a thorough assessment and open discussion of the potential consequences. While some amputations are sadly unavoidable to save a patient’s life or prevent severe harm, the misuse of such a drastic procedure in extreme situations - such as Mr Hopper’s - is both shocking and unacceptable.

What causes an amputation?

Amputations are often the result of serious medical conditions, including:

·         Severe infection to a limb such as gangrene, often linked to sepsis

·         Loss of blood supply to a limb, also known as critical limb ischaemia

·         A limb is deformed or has limited function and movement

·         Limb deformities or conditions that severely limit function and mobility

Lower limb amputations are especially common when somebody is suffering from diabetes. According to NHS Resolution in 2022, up to 85% of diabetes related amputations are avoidable with proper surveillance, early intervention and care.

Signs you may have a claim in relation to an amputation

You may have a claim if you or your family have experienced:

·         A delayed or misdiagnosis of an infection, diabetes related complications or vascular disease which has led to irreversible damage resulting in an amputation

·         Surgical errors such as operating on the wrong limb or damaging a limb beyond repair

·         Inadequate surgical aftercare leading to a severe infection or blood clot which has led to an amputation being necessary

Can I claim for my amputation?

If your amputation was avoidable and caused by negligent care, a medical negligence claim may help you:

·         Access financial compensation for pain, suffering and future care needs

·         Hold healthcare providers accountable for failures in patient safety

·         Gain a sense of closure and support changes that protect others in the future

Why it's important to act now

We understand that no level of compensation can truly undo the trauma of losing a limb. However, a successful claim can provide vital financial security for the future. It can also ensure access to the care and support you need - such as therapies, prosthetics, and carers - helping you rebuild independence and move forward with your life.

If you believe you have suffered an unnecessary or avoidable amputation, it is important to seek advice without delay. Strict time limits apply to these types of claims. In most cases, you have only three years from the date of the negligence or from the point you first became aware that something may have gone wrong to begin your claim. Although three years might sound like plenty of time, it can pass quickly. Taking action early allows solicitors to secure medical records and other crucial evidence, giving you the best possible chance of a successful outcome.

How Switalskis Can Help

If you think you may have been affected by an avoidable amputation, we encourage you to get in touch. Our dedicated team will take the time to listen to your concerns, answer your questions, and clearly explain the options available to you. You can speak with us in complete confidence by calling 0800 1380 458 or by email at help@switalskis.com .