Two found guilty of St William’s Children’s Home abuse


December 17, 2015 | By David Greenwood |

December 17, 2015 | By David Greenwood |

Two men have been found guilty of over thirty offences against children at former Approved School, St William’s Community Home, after a ten-week trial.

James Carragher, 75, the former principal of the school, and Anthony McCallen, 69, the chaplain from the late 1970s to the school’s closure in the 1990s, were accused of abuse spanning over two decades at St William’s in Market Weighton. After two weeks of deliberations, the jury found them guilty of abusing twelve boys who had been resident at the home.

Carragher was convicted of abusing 7 boys and McCallen of abusing 5 boys following a trial which painted a graphic picture of physical and sexual violence at the school, where boys who had been placed in care would be sent by local authorities.

The recent investigation into abuse at St William’s was the latest of a string of investigations into the school. In 1993, Carragher was convicted of a number of offences against boys in his care, and he was again convicted in 2004. He has previously been sentenced to 21 years in prison for his abuse of residents at the school. McCallen served a 2 ½ year sentence in the 1990s for sexual offences unrelated to St William’s. Last year, former farmer at the school, Albert Marvin, was jailed for 7 years for sexual abuse including offences at St William’s.

Both Carragher and McCallen have been remanded in custody. Sentencing will take place on 4 January 2016.

David Greenwood, Director and Head of the Child Abuse Department at Switalskis Solicitors, represents 109 survivors of abuse at St William’s. He started a civil compensation case in 2004, which remains ongoing. Commenting on the case, David said:

“The criminal prosecutions represent some justice for the survivors but the public should be aware that the boys (now men) who were at St Williams have had to endure no only the abuse itself, but not being believed by the police and social workers who they told, incomplete police investigations and years of delays caused by legal tactics of the home’s Catholic operators. Legal technicalities are to this day being used to prevent them getting compensation and restoring some dignity to their lives.

“I am hopeful that the convictions will mark a turning point in the case and that the Diocese of Middlesbrough and the De La Salle organisations will now attempt to reach an out of court settlement with the Claimants.”

For more information about this case, please contact David Greenwood on 01709 890400.

David Greenwood

David Greenwood leads our child abuse compensation team. He is an award-winning Solicitor with a national reputation in his field and a prominent campaigner for the rights of victims of childhood abuse. David's profile

Posted in

Free Guide - Moving on from Sexual Abuse

There are many aspects to moving on from past sexual abuse. It's important that you know where to begin and who to contact, and that you have a strategy for life after abuse.

In this free guide, writer Shereen Lincoln explains all the things you need to consider and shows the way towards a happier, more fulfilling life after abuse.